Grandparents who murdered toddler after campaign of horrific abuse will not have their jail sentences increased
Grandparents who murdered toddler after campaign of horrific abuse will not have their jail sentences increased
In a recent ruling, the Court of Appeal in London decided against raising the prison terms of Michael Ives and Kerry Ives, the grandparents convicted of killing their two-year-old grandson Ethan Ives-Griffiths. The pair, aged 48 and 47 respectively, were originally sentenced to life imprisonment for the crime, which followed years of severe mistreatment.
A Harrowing Tragedy
Ethan, a toddler who was found extremely dehydrated and underweight, collapsed at his grandparents’ residence in Flintshire, North Wales, in August 2021. The boy, weighing just 10 kilograms, had visible bruises and marks across his body, and a post-mortem examination revealed over 40 injuries, including catastrophic brain trauma.
Lord Justice Popplewell noted that Ethan was ‘brave’ and ‘resilient’, describing him as a child with a ‘strong character’.
During the appeal, Bill Emlyn Jones KC, representing the Solicitor General, argued that the sentences were ‘unduly lenient’, citing the grandparents’ prolonged abuse as aggravating factors. However, the appellate panel concluded that the terms were fitting, with no need for adjustment.
The Evidence and Sentencing
CCTV footage from the incident showed Michael Ives lifting his grandson by the arm and delivering a punch before placing him in a car seat. Additional clips depicted Ethan walking with an unsteady gait in the garden, potentially linked to earlier head injuries. The judge also mentioned that Michael would force Ethan to stand with his hands on his head as a form of humiliation.
The original sentencing, handed down last year by Mr Justice Griffiths, imposed a minimum of 23 years for Michael and 17 years for Kerry. The Court of Appeal confirmed these terms were appropriate, emphasizing the judge’s clear understanding of the circumstances.
Shannon Ives’ Role and Appeal
Ethan’s mother, Shannon Ives, 28, was also found guilty of causing or allowing his death and sentenced to 12 years in prison. Her legal team, led by Gordon Cole KC, contested the sentence, claiming it was ‘too long’ and that the judge overlooked her personal circumstances.
Lord Justice Popblewell stated, ‘The judge was very well placed to assess her culpability and personal mitigation.’
Ethan had been on the child protection register, requiring regular check-ins every 10 days. His mother informed a social worker on August 5 that Ethan was napping when last seen, just days before his tragic demise. The appeal panel agreed the sentence had been thoroughly considered and was not unjustified.
